Horseshoes

Horseshoes are a beloved local specialty sandwich in Springfield, Illinois. This hearty dish typically features toasted bread topped with hamburger patties or thick slices of roast beef or ham, smothered in a cheesy, savory sauce, and served with a side of crispy French fries and pickles. Each restaurant seems to have their own unique way of making it.

 

Common and Creative Variations of Horseshoe Sandwiches

Classic Horseshoe

• Toasted hearty bread, such as Texas toast, hamburger patty or sliced roast beef, crispy French fries, creamy cheese sauce.

Chicken Horseshoe

• Swap the beef patty for grilled or fried chicken breast or tenders.
• Add buffalo sauce or other seasonings for extra flavor

Vegetarian Horseshoe

• Use veggie patties, grilled portobello mushrooms, or crispy fried cauliflower.
• Top with vegetarian cheese sauces or spicy vegan cheese.

Seafood Horseshoe

• Replace the meat with fried fish fillets, shrimp, or crab cakes.
• Use a flavorful seafood or creamy dill sauce.

Spicy Horseshoe

• Incorporate spicy elements like jalapeños, hot sauce, or spicy sausage.
• Use pepper jack cheese or a spicy cheese sauce.

Breakfast Horseshoe

• Top with breakfast items like scrambled eggs, bacon, sausage, or ham.
• Use breakfast-style cheeses and add a drizzle of Hollandaise or gravy.

BBQ Horseshoe

• Use pulled pork, brisket, or BBQ chicken.
• Add BBQ sauce and toppings like coleslaw for a smoky flavor.

Gourmet Horseshoe

• Incorporate upscale ingredients like caramelized onions, sautéed mushrooms, blue cheese, or arugula.
• Use artisan bread and gourmet cheeses.

Vegetarian/Vegan Cheese Sauce Variations

• Use dairy-free cheese sauces made from cashews, nutritional yeast, or plant-based cheeses.

International Flavors

• Incorporate flavors like Mexican (with salsa, jalapeños, and queso fresco), Mediterranean (with roasted vegetables and feta), or Asian (with teriyaki chicken and scallions).

 

I can tell you that, having eaten Horseshoe sandwiches at several Springfield restaurants, you will soon discover which version you like the best!

 

Print